Associate ProfessorMark Bennett
Associate Professor
Faculty of Law
RESEARCH INTERESTS
Please see the 'Publications' tab for a list of publications.
Trusts Law: Theory, Doctrine, and Principled Limits
Mark’s largest body of work is in trusts law, particularly the theory of trusts, settlor control, illusory trusts, asset protection, and the use of trusts to avoid or subvert other areas of law.
In The Use of Trusts to Subvert the Law: An Analysis and Critique (SSRN), co-authored with Professor Adam Hofri-Winogradow and published in the Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, Mark develops a normative critique of trusts used to avoid external legal obligations. The article argues that many such uses are difficult to justify within a liberal legal system, and that legal systems need principled ways of limiting trusts when they undermine other legal regimes.
That concern with principled limits runs through much of Mark’s trusts scholarship. A recurring question in his work is when the law should respect trust form, and when it should treat that form as inconsistent with the trust’s asserted legal or normative justification.
Mark and Professor Hofri-Winogradow continue this broader critical project in Subversion as an Agenda for Critical Trusts Law Scholarship (SSRN), a chapter in Critical Trusts Law: Reading Roger Cotterrell. The chapter situates trusts scholarship within a wider inquiry into how private law forms can structure, conceal, or deflect legal responsibility.
Mark has also written extensively on illusory trusts and settlor control. His articles Competing Views on Illusory Trusts: The Clayton v Clayton Litigation in Its Wider Context (SSRN) and The Illusory Trust Doctrine: Formal or Substantive? (SSRN) examine one doctrinal setting in which this question arises. While the illusory trust doctrine is sometimes criticised as uncertain or result-driven, Mark argues that it has a defensible basis in established principles of equity. On this view, the doctrine is not simply a discretionary judicial response to hard cases. It is one way the law asks whether a purported trust has crossed the line between legitimate legal form and excessive retained control.
His comparative trusts work includes 'Asset Protection Trusts' in the Cook Islands: Boundaries and Context, co-authored with Professor Katy Barnett. The chapter examines the Cook Islands’ offshore trust regime and asks where asset protection and settlor autonomy reach their legitimate limits.
Mark’s recent work on “look-through” reasoning develops the same concern in a different doctrinal register. Rather than asking whether a trust is valid or illusory, look-through rules ask whether, for the purposes of another legal regime, assets formally held on trust should still be treated as effectively within the settlor’s control or benefit.
In 'Looking Through' Trusts in Relationship Property Redistribution Regimes: A Comparative Perspective published in the King’s Law Journal, Mark and Professor Hofri-Winogradow compare how common law jurisdictions respond when trusts are used to keep assets out of relationship property claims. Their later article, Looking Through Trusts published in the Osgoode Hall Law Journal, extends the analysis across family property, tax, and welfare means-testing.
Together, these articles examine the doctrinal techniques legal systems use to place limits on trust form without rejecting trusts altogether. Look-through reasoning is therefore closely connected to Mark’s earlier critique of trust subversion. It is one possible answer to the problem identified in that work: how can the law preserve legitimate trusts while preventing trust structures from defeating the purposes of other legal regimes?
Mark is also one of four editors of the Oxford Handbook of Comparative Trust Laws, published by Oxford University Press, with Richard Nolan, Lusina Ho, and Professor Hofri-Winogradow. The Handbook brings together leading trusts scholars from more than thirty jurisdictions. Mark also contributes a chapter on Settlor Reserved Powers, co-authored with Professor Katy Barnett and Dr Tobias Barkley.
Residential Tenancy Law
In an earlier research phase, Mark has also contributed to New Zealand residential tenancy law, particularly where legal doctrine intersects with housing quality and housing policy.
With Sarah Bierre and Professor Philippa Howden-Chapman, he co-authored Decent Expectations? The Use and Interpretation of Housing Standards in Tenancy Tribunals in New Zealand (SSRN). The article was the first systematic study of how housing quality standards were being interpreted and applied in the Tenancy Tribunal. It showed that an important dampness standard in the Housing Improvement Regulations 1947 was often being overlooked, leaving tenants without an effective remedy. The research attracted public attention and contributed to the wider movement for stronger housing quality regulation, later reflected in the Healthy Homes Standards.
In Problems in Residential Tenancy Law Revealed by Holler v Osaki, Mark analysed the uncertainty exposed by the Court of Appeal’s decision in Holler v Osaki and anticipated later legislative reform. He has also written comparatively on security of tenure in Security of Tenure for Generation Rent: Irish and Scottish Approaches arguing that New Zealand should adopt stronger 'security of tenure' protections for tenants, drawing on reforms in Ireland and Scotland.
Legal Theory and Jurisprudence
Some of Mark's earliest academic work was in legal philosophy, focusing on the relationship between legal form, legality, and moral value.
In Hart and Raz on the Non-Instrumental Moral Value of the Rule of Law: A Reconsideration (SSRN), published in Law and Philosophy, he challenges the common view that H L A Hart and Joseph Raz denied the moral significance of legality. He argues instead that their work leaves room for a more nuanced account of the moral value of conformity to rule-of-law principles.
His earlier jurisprudential work includes 'The Rule of Law' Means Literally What It Says: Fuller and Raz on Formal Legality and the Concept of Law and Leaving the Hart–Fuller Debate and Reclaiming Fuller: Form, Agency, and Morality in Kristen Rundle’s Forms Liberate.
RANGAHAU | RESEARCH
- PROJECT GRANTInternational Trusts Law Research Collaborations: Oxford Handbook and Lookthrough projectTe Herenga Waka-Victoria University of Wellington1 Jan 2023 - 31 Dec 2024People funded by this grant:
- Bennett M
- EXTERNAL GRANTEviction and its Consequences: Representation, Discourse and RealityUNIVERSITY OF OTAGO1 Mar 2018 - 31 Mar 2021
- EXTERNAL GRANTConference: Unearthing New Zealand's Constitutional TraditionsNEW ZEALAND LAW FOUNDATION1 Dec 2012 - 31 May 2014